Paneling the trainee? Or SLCS itself?

Paneling the trainee? Or SLCS itself?

For I was hungry and you gave Me something to eat, I was thirsty and you gave Me something to drink, I was a stranger and you took Me in, I was naked and you clothed Me, I was sick and you looked after Me, I was in prison and you visited Me.’

Then the righteous will answer Him, ‘Lord, when did we see You hungry and feed You, or thirsty and give You something to drink? When did we see You a stranger and take You in, or naked and clothe You? When did we see You sick or in prison and visit You?’

And the King will reply, ‘Truly I tell you, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of Mine, you did for Me.’

Matthew 25:35-40

SLCS Panels Define Who We Are

When a panel votes on a trainee we are making a choice about one specific trainee and whether or not they fit SLCS culture.

It might be less obvious, but with each trainee who Panels, we are also defining who we are. Panels are a test of what SLCS is. Of who we aspire to be.

Are we are the greatest dancers SL has ever seen? Do we go through a ruthless audition process every season cutting both trainees and veterans who don’t measure up to the highest bar? Or are we a big tent, a big stadium, with room and diversity to fit many cheerleaders, many individual styles, and many needs?

Our Identity

In one of the Star Trek movies, Kirk asks Spock about his trainees:

Spock, these cadets of yours, how good are they? How will they respond under real pressure?

In his reply, Spock paraphrases a famous saying,

As with all living things, each according to her gifts.

What has impressed me most about SLCS is how we aspire to live up to the optimism of that slogan.

Some on the squad are spectacular cheerleaders: constantly contributing, performing beautifully, inspiring audiences, and more. Others of us are not so spectacular. Yet we still find being a part of SLCS nourishing to our souls.

The most amazing fact about Jesus, unlike almost any other religious founder, is that he found God in disorder and imperfection—and told us that we must do the same or we would never be content on this earth.

Richard Rohr

The SLCS Panel Says No

The Panel recently said “no” to an autistic trainee. The trainee did not look like a cheerleader. Their communication and interaction was very low. The “no” votes all had solid reasons and serious thinking behind them.

We have in the past said “yes” to trainees who happened to be autistic. They tended to have better communication skills. They tended to look more like cheerleaders.

Although her communication skills are minimal, this trainee has had an impressive attendance record for months now. I wouldn’t want to put my attendance record up against hers. By one account I’ve heard, she has been attending SLCS not for months, but for years! She wasn’t a trainee and didn’t panel before because she was too shy. It was too hard to communicate. Whatever she lacked in dress and articulation, she made up for in desire and dedication.

After the first Panel told her no she was asked to retrain and accomplish several things. When she Paneled for the 2nd time she had accomplished every one of the things we had asked of her. In her 2nd panel she spoke more. Was it a tour de force performance by a member of the Cambridge Union? Of course not. Nowhere close. But for someone who has trouble communicating in text, she made a valiant effort to speak with the Panel and answer our questions.

The result? We defined ourselves by denying this person filled with desire a second time. She did not train and Panel yet again, so unlike Peter, we did not have the opportunity to deny Christ three times. Instead, she simply left Second Life.

RFL & The Blood-brain barrier

For years now SLCS has worked hard to contribute to The American Cancer Society’s Relay for Life (RFL). We’ve hosted countless events over many years. Shouted out for people to participate and donate. And donated what we’re able.

If you add up all the L$ donated, it’s a beautiful gift. But it does not amount to a large number of Physical World (PW) dollars to fight such a virulent disease. Is it even a drop compared to what your favorite billionaire can do? To what a responsible government should do?

As avatars our ability to aid in the troubles of PW life are minimal. If your fleshvatar is sick, we can offer thoughts and prayers. And we do. I’m sure they are of some comfort. But unlike fleshvatars, we avatars can’t go to the PW hospital room and hold your hand. We can’t yell at the doctors if we think they aren’t providing the best or enough care. We can’t donate a kidney.

The human body has a “blood-brain barrier“.

  • some substances can cross it
  • others cannot cross it

Avatars have a sort of Avatar-Fleshvatar Barrier. We can offer thoughts and prayers. Or donate L$ to RFL. Mostly we can’t do too much about the PW troubles of avatars we know and care for.

Making a Difference

The autistic trainee who was rejected was not coming to us to address PW issues. She was coming to us to belong. Her need was right here in SL where we avatars actually can do something. Of all our million hours of dance parties to make the tiniest contribution against a horrible disease, here, standing right in front of us, was a real person whose desire and dedication we had the ability to reward with membership.

It would be great if she could have made a beautiful speech about how all the love and community at SLCS calms the knots in her brain. Unfortunately, this isn’t a Hollywood movie, and she doesn’t have the ability to express lofty prose like that.

When you are a Bear of Very Little Brain, and you Think of Things, you find sometimes that a Thing which seemed very Thingish inside you is quite different when it gets out into the open and has other people looking at it.

Winnie the Pooh

The Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders

When a trainee Panels, we test their suitability for SLCS. We also test who we as SLCS are.

Of course we are neither of those. Yet we have some kinship with each of them.

We are here to look good, to express more-or-less Western beauty standards. To give great performances. To be “Second Life‘s Sweethearts.”

In my time at SLCS I have also seen us be more than that. I have seen Srooc Skytower Memorial Stadium be a very big stadium! A big stadium named after a big cheerleader. A big field with room for so many people, and so many ways of being in Second Life.

As with all living things, each according to her gifts.

Midfield at Srooc Skytower Memorial Stadium. Wearing Maddy Perennity’s gorgeous new SLCS 15th anniversary uniform. Standing at the 50-yard-line and wondering. Is the field half empty? Or half full? Which way to a touchdown? Which way to an own goal? What is SLCS? Who am I? Is there a place for me in an organization that doesn’t have a place for Rose? So many questions for an avatar of very little brain. I thought SL was supposed to be fun?
Danielle proposing to Srooc on Valentine’s Day, 2011.

4 thoughts on “0

  1. Claps. Claps. CLAPS! My dear. You have written this so well!! And the said trainee, she responds to voice. It is about adapt and overcome. It’s what we do as cheerleaders. Together and for ourselves. Not everyone who comes to SLCS is seeking that ultimate cheer girl goal. Friendship, belonging and a sense of knowing others care is what lands alot of girls in the SROOC stadium. Including myself. Aero, thank you for this beautiful post.

    1. Thanks so much, Amber!

      Honestly, when I joined SLCS “cheerleading” was all I had on my mind. It was all the kindness & caring at SLCS that forced me to elevate my world view. It was disappointing in this case to see SLCS not to live up to the higher standards that I felt like it had pushed me to believe in.

      I know cheerleaders are split on this. I’m not arguing that it’s easy. I just thought it was who we were. Do all the constant admonitions to be generous, supportive, and take care of each other stop if we don’t like the way someone dresses? Or if they aren’t articulate enough to say in words what SLCS means to them even though their remarkable participation record over many months says it more clearly in deeds than words could ever say?

      I didn’t know she used voice! Or was better with voice than with text. I just listened to a talk by Jenny Lay-Flurrie, Chief Accessibility Officer at Microsoft. It was a good talk about finding accommodations that work for human beings.

      PS: thank you for letting me tag along to your club the other night – it was fun! In case you haven’t seen it already, I posted a few pix of us dancing in the street:

      Have a good week ahead, Amber!

  2. As a former head of training, stories like this are heartbreaking because to me, rejecting a trainee simply because they are different is NOT what SLCS is about at all. To me SLCS is about giving people a place to feel loved and belonging and anyone who shows desire and enough determination to make it to panel, at least deserves a chance. Many members who may not be the best at running the hud or even performing, have found a place at SLCS and become very valuable members. I eventually left training all together because for some, panels seem like nothing more than a power play or way to show superiority. The panel process can be very toxic at times and honestly, i would be happy to see it go away altogether.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Previous post Hero Blessed
Next post Goodnight kiss from Abbie

Authors @Kate

  1. Another Followup --- It's mid-October and all the Halloween installations are raging. This "Top SL Haunted Places" notice came in…

  2. Update: CoffeeSluts of Second Life just republished their 4-1/2 page, 1,482 word, Group Guidelines. It's here: ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Rules:…

  3. As a former head of training, stories like this are heartbreaking because to me, rejecting a trainee simply because they…